Fox Valley Roofing Contractors
Explore established roofing contractors serving Appleton, Neenah, Menasha, Oshkosh, and surrounding Fox Valley, Wisconsin communities, with a focus on years in business, public reputation, review strength, and homeowner trust signals.
Storm damage repair, full replacements, and long-lasting residential roofing systems.
How this category is organized
Listings are intended to prioritize established roofing contractors with stronger longevity, review signals, and relevant residential roofing fit.
See how Most Experienced Contractors ranks local contractorsRanking signals
Category overview
Browse Fox Valley roofing contractors serving Appleton, Neenah, Menasha, Oshkosh, and nearby communities, ranked for experience, local trust indicators, and strong residential fit.
Long-running Fox Valley roofing company with 90 years of public roofing history, high review volume, and a broad residential and commercial service footprint.
Large exterior remodeler with an Appleton/Fox Valley location, strong review volume, and roofing, siding, window, door, and gutter services.
Established Oshkosh-area roofing and exterior contractor serving the Fox Valley with residential roofing, commercial roofing, siding, gutters, and roof repair services.
Green Bay and Northeast Wisconsin roofing contractor with more than 30 years of experience, owner involvement on every job site, and strong public review signals.
Oshkosh-based roofing specialist focused exclusively on roofing, with residential and light commercial experience across Oshkosh and the Fox Valley.
Locally owned Fox Valley exterior contractor with decades of roofing, siding, gutter, window, door, and storm-damage experience.
Why these contractors
The roofing shortlist favors companies with established operating histories, meaningful public review evidence, and a clear roofing or exterior-service footprint in the Fox Valley. The group includes long-running Appleton, Neenah, and Oshkosh-area businesses as well as contractors with broader Northeast Wisconsin reach. Years in business is a major signal, but MEC also considers review strength, public rating, local relevance, and how closely each company fits the roofing category.
Fox Valley context
The contractors in this comparison serve homeowners across the Fox Valley with work that includes roof replacement, roof repair, asphalt shingles, metal roofing, low-slope systems, storm-damage work, gutters, siding, and other exterior services. Service areas vary by company, so homeowners should confirm that a contractor serves their specific city and that its project experience matches the roofing system or repair being considered.
Quick comparison
This table keeps the same MEC ranking order shown below. Years in business, ratings, and review counts are research snapshots and may change as listings are updated.
| Rank | Contractor | Base | Years | Rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Security-Luebke Roofing | Appleton | 90 | 4.7 | 542 |
| #2 | Ridge Top Exteriors | Appleton | 24 | 4.7 | 537 |
| #3 | Motto & Sons Roofing & Construction | Oshkosh | 60 | 4.7 | 129 |
| #4 | Machkovich Roofing LLC | Green Bay | 30 | 4.9 | 162 |
| #5 | Hickey Roofing | Oshkosh | 41 | 4.8 | 88 |
| #6 | Fox Valley Roofing & Siding | Neenah | 47 | 4.2 | 62 |
Fox Valley Roofing questions
These answers are based on the contractor data used in this category comparison. Ratings and review counts are snapshots, while years-in-business claims are based on the research sources recorded for each listing.
By longest documented operating history in this MEC comparison, Security-Luebke Roofing leads at 90 years in business. MEC's overall ranking is separate and also considers public review count, rating, local relevance, and category fit.
Security-Luebke Roofing currently ranks #1 in this category using MEC's composite Experience Score. The score combines years in business, public review count, and public rating, while the underlying research also considers local relevance and category fit.
Security-Luebke Roofing has the largest public review count in this MEC comparison at 542 reviews at the last recorded check. Review totals can change over time.
MEC started with a broader Fox Valley roofing candidate pool and compared documented operating history, public ratings and review volume, local service presence, and roofing relevance. The final listings are meant to surface experienced, credible companies worth comparing rather than every roofer in the market.
Compare documented years in business, roofing specialization, public review volume and rating, the contractor’s service area, and whether its experience matches your project type. For a roof replacement or repair, also confirm current licensing or credential requirements, insurance, scope, warranty terms, and the exact materials being proposed before hiring.
Related MEC research
MEC Research
A cross-trade look at long-running contractors in MEC research, including businesses with operating histories reaching back more than a century.
Read the guideResearch Process
Why a company founding date and a legal-entity registration date can differ, and how MEC evaluates conflicting business-history signals.
Read the guide2026 Local Cost Guide
A 2026 planning guide to Appleton and Fox Valley roof replacement pricing, current local benchmarks, cost drivers, and quote-comparison questions.
Read the guideNeed Roofing Help?
Fill out the form and your contact info will be sent to the most experienced contractor.